[thepossum]

Sorry I dont have the hand because I refused to play it

All I am saying is, 1S, game force 2D (5 diamonds), 2S, 3H (4 of them), 4H (3 of them)

I dont play with useless partners or systems if I can help it

[hrothgar]

thepossum, on 2020-November-27, 04:23, said:

Sorry I dont have the hand because I refused to play it

All I am saying is, 1S, game force 2D (5 diamonds), 2S, 3H (4 of them), 4H (3 of them)

I dont play with useless partners or systems if I can help it

I'm not going to comment about GIB's bidding without seeing the hand, with this said and done

There are a lot of cases in which a seven card fit (especially a 4-3 fit) is going to be the correct place to declare a contract.

Learning when this holds true and how to play these hands is very much part of developing as a bridge player.
You can't just write off players or partners because the chose to place you in a Moysian.

[smerriman]

hrothgar, on 2020-November-27, 07:07, said:

There are a lot of cases in which a seven card fit (especially a 4-3 fit) is going to be the correct place to declare a contract.

Exactly.

Give GIB something like AQJxx KQx x xxxx and you would get the bidding sequence mentioned, and it would clearly be correct.