Apologies if this has been covered before.
A couple of my favorite partners are split on what is required for North's rebid.
In example #1 partner argues for a hand of reversing strength. I think this makes sense, but would like some expert feedback on the relative merits.
In example #2 there is agreement that no extra strength is required.
I'm interested in what you would rebid something like:
If 2♦ promises extra's then clearly that rebid cannot be made, but change the red suits around and you have an easy 2♥ call.
Does that make sense?
P.S. If you open these 1♦ then you would not have this problem, for me they are both 1♣